Mike

          Mike Heap's Blog


Insights, thoughts, and ideas — straight from Sheffield.



The Rise and Rise of Diagnosis in Mental Health Problems

Written on November 18, 2026

At the time of my earliest studies of psychology in the 1960s, there was much discussion about what was the right approach to understanding and treating psychological disorders and distress such as disabling anxiety and depression, severe behavioural difficulties, and psychosis. One dispute was whether these problems should be understood as symptoms of some physical pathology and should be treated accordingly, notably by medicine or procedures such as ECT or surgery, or as manifestations of underlying psychological difficulties rooted in the person's environment and life experiences and to be treated as such. The former approach was labelled the 'medical (or biological) model' as opposed to the psychological approach.

The medical model was much more favoured by psychiatrists, who are all medically trained, whereas psychologists and psychotherapists, as would be expected, much preferred the alternative approach. There were several reasons for this, which I won't go into here except to say that one frequent criticism of the medical model was that for many disorders there was no definitive evidence of any underlying biological pathology.

These days, opinion is less polarised and it is acknowledged that mental health disorders most often arise from a combination of biological, psychological and social factors, hence the term 'the biopsychosocial model'. Nevertheless, this more holistic approach retains the framework of physical medicine in practice-i.e. we have the presenting symptoms, a diagnosis, some underlying cause or pathology (known or hypothesised), treatment, prognosis, relapse, etc.

It is the persistence of this framework that bothers many psychologists and psychotherapists. Central to their objections is the use of the term 'diagnosis', which in many cases (less so with very serious mental illnesses) is merely a descriptive label for the person's presenting problems and therefore of limited explanatory value. For example, if I am experiencing a persistent state of anxiety, out of all proportion to the stresses and strains of my daily life, and in the absence of any causative biological defect, a psychiatrist might diagnose me with Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD). But this would be little more than a statement of what I am going through; likewise Major Depressive Disorder if my mood were constantly very low.

Now, in everyday practice, this is not much of an issue, because very often (though not always) whatever the diagnosis is, it is the symptoms or problems that are the focus of treatment. To understand this, it may help to be aware that diagnoses for mental disorders are mainly based on tallies of one or more clusters of symptoms, usually with their severity, duration, and frequency, being specified. If these exceed a certain threshold (decided by a committee of psychiatrists and available in publications such as the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) then the person is deemed to be suffering from that disorder.

But what if the patient's symptoms and problems fall short of the diagnostic criteria for any specific mental disorder? Well, they are still troubled by them, and the practitioner may still prescribe or administer treatment or therapy that is likely to benefit the person. Thus, again, it is the symptoms that are being treated, not the disorder as such (note 1).

Until relatively recently, although diagnostic labels were in common usage in routine psychotherapeutic and clinical psychological practice, the question of a patient's or client's formal diagnosis was seldom a significant issue, once a good understanding of what the person's presenting problems were. (See note 2. In those days, we tended to avoid undertaking therapy with patients who had severe mental illnesses). But in recent times it has become a matter of much greater significance amongst the professions. Witness also (as I have pointed out in previous posts) the huge rise in the number of diagnosable mental disorders. Notice also the readiness of lay people to use diagnostic labels to explain their difficulties and struggles and those of others.

So, what is driving all of this?

Notes

1. An example: a prisoner I once saw had been complaining of 'hearing voices', a symptom of psychosis. He was seen by a psychiatrist, whose opinion was that he did not have a psychotic illness. Nevertheless, the psychiatrist prescribed him antipsychotic medication, and the prisoner was reporting some benefit.

2. An exception would be (notwithstanding the above footnote) the diagnosis of a psychotic disorder such as schizophrenia, which if 'missed' would result in the patient not receiving the appropriate medication.

In future posts I'll try to answer the question posed above.


Note: At present, it's not possible for you to post your comments on my blog directly. But I welcome them via my email address, and I'll only upload them under 'Comments' if that is your wish (and with the usual stipulations about offensiveness, etc.)